The Kerala government has come under scrutiny over its involvement in the removal of social media content, following conflicting statements by Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan and Home Minister Ramesh Chennithala. The Home Minister's recent response in the Assembly has raised questions about the government's earlier denial of issuing instructions to Meta to take down posts critical of the Chief Minister and his administration.
The discrepancy came to light on Tuesday when Chennithala's replies to Assembly questions concerning the removal of social media posts were made public. In response to an unstarred question raised by CPI(M) MLA Xavier Chittilappally about action taken against news cards and online posts featuring photographs of the Chief Minister and other ministers, Chennithala confirmed that notices had been sent to social media platforms requesting the removal of certain content.
According to the Home Minister, the notices concerned photographs and images allegedly manipulated through artificial intelligence (AI) or morphing techniques. The government initiated the action under the provisions of the Information Technology Act and Rules through the Union government's Sahyog portal. The platform, established by the Union Ministry of Home Affairs, serves as a centralised mechanism for government agencies to communicate content-removal requests to social media companies, telecom operators and other online intermediaries.
Chennithala further informed the Assembly that the government had received 4,201 complaints relating to the circulation of AI-generated or manipulated photographs and videos, including content depicting the Chief Minister and other ministers. Legal proceedings were initiated in 3,472 cases, according to his response. He also revealed that 15,627 social media posts and links had been removed since the present UDF government assumed office.
These disclosures have raised questions because they appear inconsistent with Satheesan's position during a press conference on August 13. At the time, the Chief Minister had denied that he or his government had instructed Meta to remove social media content critical of him or the administration. Instead, he maintained that certain posts expressing support for him had also been taken down by the platform.
Satheesan had also indicated that the government was willing to intervene if media organisations reported the removal of their online content. He offered to communicate with Meta and other social media intermediaries to ensure that posts criticising him were not subjected to removal and that affected content could be restored.
The controversy has gained further significance following two recent Kerala High Court rulings that allowed a digital news platform and a farmers' organisation to regain access to their Facebook accounts after Meta had blocked them. The proceedings brought attention to separate instances in which the police had reportedly directed Meta to restrict particular posts or disable entire accounts.
The latest Assembly disclosures have therefore renewed concerns over the extent of government and police intervention in regulating online content. The contrasting positions adopted by the Chief Minister and Home Minister have also raised questions about the transparency and consistency of the government's approach towards social media restrictions and criticism of those in power.